June 19, 2009
British Columbia court finds bias in board ruling
Temporary workers’ case needs fresh hearing, union says
The BC Supreme Court has overturned a BC Labour Relations Board (LRB) decision because of bias.
The controversial case involved temporary foreign workers employed in the construction of the Canada Line.
In 2006, the Construction and Specialized Workers’ Union Local 1611 launched a series of unfair labour practices complaints against Canada Line employers, SELI Canada and SNC-Lavalin Constructors Pacific.
The union alleged the employer was discouraging workers from being members of the union and frustrating the collective bargaining process.
In the original decision, the vice-chair of the LRB, Philip Topalian, declined the union’s application for an interim order, which would prohibit anti-union activities.
“In conclusion, having found actual bias, I order the decision of the board, which includes the decision of the original panel and the reconsideration panel, quashed,” said Justice Paul Walker in his decision late last month.
“It is vital for labour relations in this province that the board’s processes be viewed as impartial and procedurally fair.”
Justice Walker concluded that an informed and reasonable observer could understand that there was a bent towards one side or a particular result on the part of the vice- chair towards the union’s evidence about the fraud.
In its initial complaint, the union alleged the employer had contravened the Labour Relations Code, when it attempted to transfer foreign workers from the Canada Line project in Vancouver to Brazil.
The union said the employer’s efforts were intended to discourage its employees from becoming or continuing to be members in a trade union.
It was also alleged the employer violated the Labour Relations Code by increasing the wages of its employees in the four month freeze period following certification. The purpose of the freeze is to avoid any influence on the bargaining process.
“LRB vice-chair Philip Topalian has been found by the BC Supreme Court to have exhibited actual bias against the union in this case and in favour of the employer, contrary to all requirements of fairness that the court expects should be shown,” said the union’s business manager Mark Olsen.
“This is a serious matter and our union does not take this step lightly, but Justice Walker’s decision is highly critical of Mr. Topalian’s conduct in a very important case that could have far-reaching impacts on B.C. labour relations law.”
The case involved about 40 temporary foreign workers, who were earning only $4 per hour or US$1,000 per month, plus room and board for a minimum of 60 hours per week, until their situation was made public by the union.
|MOST POPULAR STORIES|
- OPG $1 billion proposal to bury nuclear waste up for comment
- Hundreds of workers to be out of work as Caterpillar Inc. is set to close Toronto factory
- Proposed Ambassador Bridge twinning draws Windsor mayor’s ire
- Construction on pedestrian tunnel to Billy Bishop Airport continues to make progress
- Ontario prompt payment bill to get second reading today
- 20 Most Popular Stories
|TODAY’S TOP CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS|
These projects have been selected from 316 projects with a total value of $2,787,806,637 that Reed Construction Data Building Reports reported on Friday.
$90,000,000 Richmond Hill ON Prebid
$82,000,000 White River Twp ON Tenders
$40,650,000 Markham ON Prebid
- VIDEO: Economic Update May 21, 2013
- VIDEO: Competing in the trades
- Multi-employer approach needed in apprenticeships
- New Perspective
- ACEC’s input helps develop global engineering guidelines
- Clerk of works position gives peace of mind on projects
- World Trade Center developer’s plan for a 926-foot tower moving ahead
- Call for action after MOL says workers are responsible for their own safety
- Cold spring and weak construction hurt Deere’s 2013 predictions
- CanBIM reschedule June session
- More green roofs top Toronto buildings
- Witness recants testimony in Montreal corruption case
- Construction Site Arson
- Industry reacts to surprise B.C. Liberal majority
- Journal of Commerce Update for the week of May 20th, 2013
- Calgary Airport Tunnel
- Worker at centre of union sign up allegations speaks out
- Calgary program aims to get more people into the trades
- Midrise in the City
- Veterans battle barriers into the trades
- Government makes changes to online tendering
- SNC-Lavalin maintains that new bribery allegations have been resolved
- B.C. faces a tough battle for top talent
- Keyano College building state of the art training facility
- Essential skills can play a vital role in an apprentices' success
- Taking a closer look at the risks in green building for contractors
- Colleges conduct construction research in addition to teaching
- Skills Canada BC Competition
- Lower Mainland high school trades program is unique
- Construction Learning Forum aims to educate
- High schools looking for more industry participation
- Industrial construction supervisor program takes off
- Saskatchewan bill passed
- Edmonton garners support for regional cash for arena
- Feds pledge $5 million for Vimy memorial
|ALEX’S ECONOMICS BLOG|
Reed Construction Data Canada’s Chief Economist Alex Carrick discusses current developments in the North American economic environment with emphasis on the construction industry.
- An Overview of Prices and Sales in the Diverging U.S. and Canadian Housing Markets (April 25, 2013)
- Canada’s Precarious Dependence on the Commodity Price Super-Cycle (April 22, 2013)
- Twenty major upcoming residential and transportation terminal construction projects - April 2013 (April 15, 2013)