September 28, 2004
Early termination clause makes for wise policy
Editor’s note: This is part two of series which began Friday, Sept. 24 in DCN.
The Plaintiff’s damages could not be assessed on a “tort-like” basis when the Plaintiff had voluntarily capped those damages by agreeing to a three-month termination clause. The Court stated:
“The relative contractual duties have been expressly set out by the parties in the agreement. Hamilton is entitled to OWB’s performance of these voluntarily assumed duties.
“Hamilton has no compensable interest in the advantages she might have expected under any particular performance of the contract, since the contract itself provided for alternative methods of performance at the election of the Defendant.
“If Hamilton wanted to secure herself of the benefits associated with a given particular method of performance, she should have contracted for only that method of performance.”
The same rationale would seem to apply to a term contract with an early termination clause. Hamilton was an exclusive agent for Open Window and thus had that degree of vulnerability which has led some courts to provide such agents with special, employment-like protections, including an implied term of reasonable notice.
Nonetheless, the Court felt in this case that freedom of contract was the governing principle and that there was no reason to look behind it.
Naturally, issues which might affect whether a party had true freedom to contract, such as unconscionability, could still be used to defeat an oppressive contract, but the principle of assessing damages by a contractual rather than a tort measure has gained reinforcement from this case and would appear to apply equally to an employment as to an agency relationship.
The Court held in Hamilton that a court should set aside a costs award on appeal only if the trial judge has made an error in principle or if the costs award is plainly wrong.
In reviewing the trial judge’s decision, the Supreme Court of Canada could not find such an error and, given the privileged position of a trial judge in assessing first-hand the credibility of witnesses, and the factdriven nature of a case such as this, it restored the trial judge’s cost order.
This case suggests that, as we have frequently advised our clients, it is indeed a wise policy to incorporate an early termination clause into a term contract of employment.
Term contracts of employment can result in significantly higher damages than the common law if the termination occurs early in the term, since the balance of the term usually constitutes the outside limit of damages.
An early termination clause restores what, if it is not the equivalent of reasonable notice, is at least a limit on the quantum of damages in the event of termination, and avoids disproportionately high damages if the termination occurs early in the term, and disproportionately low damages if at the end of the term.
We continue to advocate this approach, and are glad to see it bolstered by the reasons set out in this Supreme Court of Canada case.
Allison Taylor practices employment law with Stringer Brisbin Humphrey in Toronto. ataylor@sbh lawyers.com
The information contained here is for general information only and should not be relied upon as a substitute for legal advice or opinion.
|MOST POPULAR STORIES|
|TODAY’S TOP CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS|
These projects have been selected from 433 projects with a total value of $3,210,413,882 that Reed Construction Data Building Reports reported on Thursday.
$210,000,000 Toronto ON Prebid
$110,000,000 Toronto ON Tenders
$51,500,000 Milton ON Negotiated
- CCA96th: Unlocking Canada's Potential
- VIDEO: LiUNA Local 183 Training Centre introduces new programs
- Wins delivered on infrastructure front: Rizzardo
- Behind the Velodrome’s Veil
- Ontario’s prompt payment bill needs work but supported
- Southwest L-evation
- Post-bid clarifications make feds liable for bid repair
- Panama Construction Fact for Today
- Ritchie Bros. hold first Canadian auction of 2014
- Skilled labour needs changing in Saskatchewan
- Quebec’s construction momentum ebbs after 15 years of expansion
- VIDEO: Canadian Construction Association conference Panama preview
- Concerns raised about P3 approach for Saskatchewan schools
- Journal of Commerce Preview for the week of March 10th, 2014
- Wood Design Awards
- Lone bidder prepares P3 proposal for Alberta schools
- Outgoing chair reflects on time at the helm of the CCA
- School board asks for traditional procurement
- Site Services in Vancouver
- Looking to improve contract awards
- Environmental verdict riles Taseko
- Prentice to mediate First Nations agreements
- CAWIC funded to create action plan to attract women
- More video surveillance used on construction sites
- Modular workforce housing meets Alberta Building Code standard
- Manitoba outlines infrastructure plan
- BC Hydro posts RFQ for Site C project