September 14, 2007
Hamilton city council debates financial impact of exclusive carpenters’ union deals
Staff report claims current deal costs city an extra $10 million
The City of Hamilton is free to negotiate with any and all construction labour unions for future non-ICI work. However, officials are bound to a 2005 deal signed with the carpenters’ union for certain projects, politicians were told.
“As it concerns heavy and residential (construction), you are within your power to negotiate what is right,” Joseph Mancinelli, Labourers’ International Union of North America international vice-president, told Hamilton City Council.
“As it concerns ICI, you have no choice but to accept (the current carpenter deal.)”
The war of words erupted this week as Hamilton politicians met to discuss the financial impacts of using union construction labour on city projects.
Hamilton has appealed to Ontario’s labour ministry to amend the Labour Relations Act allowing municipalities to be recognized as non-construction employers.
Being tied with one union hits city coffers with up $10 million in cost increases on standard capital projects, according to a City of Hamilton staff report.
The city entered into exclusive certification with the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America (UBCJA) Local 18 in 2005.
Over the next eight years, city staff said the certification would cost Hamilton an additional $440 million on its $1.1 billion water and wastewater projects.
Harold Caley, representing UBCJA Local 18, suggested city officials do not have enough information regarding escalating costs due to certification. He said an information “comfort level is needed” before they make any decision on current or future collective agreements covering heavy and residential work.
The carpenters union is currently seeking non-ICI collective agreements with Hamilton.
Entering an exclusive agreement limits the city’s ability to find the best price for work, city staff warned councillors.
Hamilton has a list of 260 large construction contractors but only 17 have UBCJA affiliation. As it concerns its water and wastewater projects, of the five contractors who perform the majority of this type of work in Canada, none are affiliated with UBCJA.
“With water and wastewater projects, you are building a machine,” explained Jeff Pigott, Kenaidan Contracting Ltd. Vice-president. “There is only a small pool of contractors who do that.”
Pigott noted Kenaidan is one of the five contractors which would be excluded if the city exclusively went with the carpenters for non-ICI work.
Mancinelli also stressed that 3,200 LIUNA members live in Hamilton and 60,000 in the surrounding region. An exclusive contract with the carpenters for non-ICI work would affect these families directly. He also points to the expertise and dominance LIUNA-member companies have in the non-ICI field. This experience helps “save the city money and taxpayers money,” said Mancinelli.
The Hamilton District Heavy Construction Association noted there would be “catastrophic” effects if the city exclusively went with the carpenters union for non-ICI work. The association represents 69 companies which have performed over 90 per cent of the city’s municipal projects over the last two years.
Joe Lieberman, representing the association, told council the city’s field of qualified bidders for non-ICI “would dwindle to next to none” if it entered the exclusive non-ICI agreement.
Caley said UBCJA Local 18’s door is open to council members concerning negotiation and any questions they may have. He added the carpenters “are not imposing anything on anybody.”
Hamilton council will still pursue its Labour Relations Act amendment. The council will also instruct staff to explore the legalities and issues concerning an exclusive agreement.
|MOST POPULAR STORIES|
- PCL Constructors works on Humber River Regional Hospital in Toronto
- Tower Hill unveils 56-storey condo tower project
- Hundreds of workers to be out of work as Caterpillar Inc. is set to close Toronto factory
- OPG $1 billion proposal to bury nuclear waste up for comment
- London association withdraws from COCA
- 20 Most Popular Stories
|TODAY’S TOP CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS|
These projects have been selected from 316 projects with a total value of $2,787,806,637 that Reed Construction Data Building Reports reported on Friday.
$90,000,000 Richmond Hill ON Prebid
$82,000,000 White River Twp ON Tenders
$40,650,000 Markham ON Prebid
- VIDEO: Competing in the trades
- Multi-employer approach needed in apprenticeships
- New Perspective
- ACEC’s input helps develop global engineering guidelines
- Clerk of works position gives peace of mind on projects
- World Trade Center developer’s plan for a 926-foot tower moving ahead
- Call for action after MOL says workers are responsible for their own safety
- Cold spring and weak construction hurt Deere’s 2013 predictions
- CanBIM reschedule June session
- More green roofs top Toronto buildings
- Witness recants testimony in Montreal corruption case
- Construction Site Arson
- Journal of Commerce Update for the week of May 20th, 2013
- Industry reacts to surprise B.C. Liberal majority
- Calgary Airport Tunnel
- Worker at centre of union sign up allegations speaks out
- Calgary program aims to get more people into the trades
- Midrise in the City
- Veterans battle barriers into the trades
- Government makes changes to online tendering
- SNC-Lavalin maintains that new bribery allegations have been resolved
- B.C. faces a tough battle for top talent
- Keyano College building state of the art training facility
- Essential skills can play a vital role in an apprentices' success
- Taking a closer look at the risks in green building for contractors
- Colleges conduct construction research in addition to teaching
- Skills Canada BC Competition
- Lower Mainland high school trades program is unique
- Construction Learning Forum aims to educate
- High schools looking for more industry participation
- Industrial construction supervisor program takes off
- Saskatchewan bill passed
- Edmonton garners support for regional cash for arena
- Feds pledge $5 million for Vimy memorial
|ALEX’S ECONOMICS BLOG|
Reed Construction Data Canada’s Chief Economist Alex Carrick discusses current developments in the North American economic environment with emphasis on the construction industry.
- An Overview of Prices and Sales in the Diverging U.S. and Canadian Housing Markets (April 25, 2013)
- Canada’s Precarious Dependence on the Commodity Price Super-Cycle (April 22, 2013)
- Twenty major upcoming residential and transportation terminal construction projects - April 2013 (April 15, 2013)