LATEST NEWS Professional Services
March 7, 2005
Who is entitled to a valid claim for lien?
Very recently an Ontario Court ruled that the work performed in removing hundreds of thousands of tires from a tire dump was an improvement to the land that qualified for a lien under the Construction Lien Act.
The cry went out: Where will this end if a tire remover is given a lien against the owners property?
To see how this matter unfolds we must go back to the Construction Lien Act itself. The Act says “a person who supplies services or materials to an improvement” has a lien for that improvement.
Improvement is defined as “any alteration, addition or repair to any land”.
The court held that removal of tires constituted both alteration and repair of the land.
Had the evidence ended there I would have concluded that the work was not lienable.
The court, however, heard evidence that the tires had been declared a contaminant within the meaning of the environmental protection act of Ontario, and the judge followed a 1998 case where contaminated soil was removed from the land, which work was found lienable.
Therefore contamination resting on the surface and that below the surface of the land were lumped into the same category.
This case may be pushing the envelope of lienability and therefore the motto for lien claimants lawyers should be: If in doubt register a lien. This would appear to be a good course to follow.
I was just advised by counsel on this case that the owner is appealing the judge’s verdict. Another article on this topic is likely to follow.
David I. Bristow is a partner with Team Resolution in Toronto. www.teamresolution.ca.
E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org. (416) 597-6585.
|MOST POPULAR STORIES|
|TODAY’S TOP CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS|
These projects have been selected from 333 projects with a total value of $13,209,890,621 that Reed Construction Data Building Reports reported on Thursday.
$150,000,000 Toronto ON Negotiated
$35,000,000 Chatham ON Negotiated
$26,000,000 Sudbury ON Tenders
- NTCCC takes to Parliament Hill tomorrow
- Emerald Park Progress
- “Super beam” installed in Montreal Champlain Bridge repair
- Is there energy gold to be mined in sewage processing?
- Ottawa LRT tunnel boring machines named
- Better transportation key to quality of life, states CivicAction
- Three World Cup stadiums behind schedule
- Ontario introduces legislation to help protect vulnerable workers
- Istanbul’s Grand Bazaar inspires design of new strip mall currently being built in Las Vegas
- VIDEO: Journal of Commerce Update for the week of December 9th, 2013
- Building the One
- New design-build contracts released
- Sales tax transition has been a mixed bag for industry
- Taseko files for judicial review of gold mine assessment
- Contract uncertainty and price escalation
- Edmonton college expansion moves ahead
- Council of Construction Associations names Dave Baspaly as new president
- $100 million added to Calgary's capital budget
- Massive investment will complete Kitimat smelter project
- Manitoba invests $45 million
- Corruption charge in probe of SNC-Lavalin